15 Comments

Dr. Michael Brown’s Critical Paper On “In Defense of Israel”


As was posted a few days ago here, The Threshing Floor had requested a copy of the soon to be released paper written by Michael Brown concerning Hagee’s claims in his newest book. Also from my understanding this was to be sent out to many Christian leaders today. Tonight The Threshing Floor has received and posted a copy of the letter:

********

An assessment of this statement and relevant commentary will be addressed on a Threshing Floor audio soon.

IS THERE SERIOUS ERROR IN THE NEW BOOK, IN DEFENSE OF ISRAEL?

by Dr. Michael L. Brown

Pastor John Hagee’s new book, In Defense of Israel: The Bible’s Mandate for Supporting the Jewish State (Lake Mary, Florida: Front Line, 2007), was publicized by announcements stating that the book would “shake Christian theology.” The following positions are explicitly laid out in the book:

-The Jewish people, as a whole, did not reject Jesus as Messiah.
-Jesus did not come to earth to be the Messiah.
-Jesus refused by word and deed to be the Messiah.
-The Jews cannot be blamed for not accepting what was never offered.

Statements like this must be evaluated in light of 1 John 2:22: “Who is the liar? It is the man who denies that Jesus is the Christ [i.e., Messiah]. Such a man is the antichrist—he denies the Father and the Son.” As commentator Stephen S. Smalley explained, “The true believer is the one who accepts the Christhood of Jesus, whereas those who deny his messianic identity declare themselves to be on the side of the antichrist” (Word Biblical Commentary).

What could possibly be the motivation for teaching such error? First, In Defense of Israel desires to dispel once and for all the notion that all Jews are Christ-killers, a terrible lie that has fueled anti-Semitism in the Church for more than 1,500 years. Second, the book wants to refute the false teaching of replacement theology, explaining that, “Replacement theologians have said that ‘the covenant with Israel was broken because she would not accept Jesus Christ whom God sent.’” (See p. 132 of In Defense of Israel.) Tragically, in the attempt to fight against these serious errors, a more serious error has now been introduced. Yet some believers – and even leaders! – are buying into this error hook, line, and sinker, and some have begun to teach and preach it as well.

Since the publication of the book, Pastor Hagee issued some clarifying remarks, but the clarifications only complicate the issues and fail to renounce and remove the error.

Here are three fundamental statements that all believers should be able to affirm without hesitation:

1) Jesus came to be the Messiah. This is the fundamental message of the New Testament, which is why we call him “Christ” (meaning, “Messiah”). And it is a fundamental message of the Scriptures that the Messiah had to suffer and die if he was one day to rule and reign (see, e.g., Luke 24:25-27, 44-47), a biblical truth that most of the Jewish people of Yeshua’s day missed, a biblical truth that most Jews through the ages have continued to miss, and a biblical truth that In Defense of Israel has now fed into as well.

In the clarifying statements that made since the publication of his book, it was explained that Jesus came to be the suffering Messiah but not the reigning Messiah – something, of course, that we all knew, and something that would hardly “shake Christian theology” – but these statements have simply introduced another nuance to the error, since nowhere in the New Testament is such a distinction made.

In other words, God did not say to Israel, “It’s fine that you rejected Jesus as Messiah because he did not come in the political way you expected. He had to die in order to be the Savior of the world, so you are not guilty.” There is not a hint of such a message in the Scriptures, which simply proclaim him as the Messiah, period.

That’s why Jesus explicitly identified himself as the Messiah in the Gospels (see, e.g., Matt 16:16-17; Mark 14:61-62; Luke 7:20-23; John 4:25-26; 5:39, 45-47; 10:24-25) – not as the suffering Messiah, whom his people were supposed to reject so that he could die, as opposed to the reigning Messiah, whom they would one day receive, but simply as the Messiah – and that’s why the Gospel authors frequently announced him as the Messiah (in Greek, the Christ; see, e.g., Luke 2:11, 26; John 1:41; 3:28; 11:27; 20:31). And that’s why the apostles proclaimed him as the Messiah in Acts (see, e.g., Acts 2:31, 36; 3:18, 20; 4:26; 5:42; 8:5; 9:22; 17:2-3; 18:5, 28; 26:23).

I would encourage you to look up every reference cited here. It is all quite simple, forthright, and easy to understand, and nowhere is any distinction made between the suffering and reigning Messiah. To repeat: Jesus is proclaimed as the Messiah of Israel, period, and because he is the Messiah of Israel, he is the Savior of the world.

 *********

 2) The Jewish people rejected their Messiah. Although all Jews are not Christ-killers (God forbid!), and although the entire Jewish nation did not play a role in the crucifixion of Jesus, God held the Jewish people in Jesus’ day responsible for his death and, more significantly, he held them responsible for rejecting Jesus the Messiah after his resurrection. The New Testament witness is explicit and consistent on this.

That’s why the apostles preached to “the people of Israel” that they were guilty of rejecting the Messiah (Acts 2:22-23, 36; 3:13-15, 17, 19; 4:10-11; 5:30; 7:52; 13:27-28; see also John 1:12), and that’s why Paul spoke of Israel’s hardening, breaking off, stumbling, transgression, and rejection (see Rom 9:31; 10:3; 11:7, 11-12, 15, 20 – although with the full expectation of Israel’s future redemption; see Rom 11:11-15, 25-26). Again, I encourage you to take a moment to look up these passages. They are striking in their force and consistency.

Because of this rejection, severe judgment came on the Jewish people in the first century, as prophesied by Yeshua with tears (see Luke 19:41-44; see also Matt 23:29-37) and as taught in his parables (see, e.g., Matt 21:33-46; 22:1-14).

As painful as this witness is, it cannot be rewritten, nor can anyone lessen Israel’s guilt because it was God’s will that Jesus died on the cross. To the contrary, just as it was God’s will that Joseph be sold into Egyptian slavery and yet at the same time his brothers were guilty of sinning against him (Gen 44:16-45:5; 50:14-20), so also it was God’s will that Yeshua die for our sins while at the same time the Jewish people, along with Herod and Pilate and the Romans, were guilty of having him crucified (see Acts 2:22-24; 4:27-28).

It is scripturally impossible to claim that “the Jews cannot be blamed for not accepting what was never offered.” A glorious offer was made and refused, and that’s why Paul’s heart was broken (see Rom 9:1-5).

*********

3) Jesus remains the Jewish Messiah, and there is no salvation for the Jewish people outside of faith in him. Although Pastor Hagee has consistently stated that he does not teach “dual covenant” theology, referring to the false concept that Jews can be saved outside of faith in Jesus, his new teaching certainly aids and abets that error. After all, if “The Jews Did Not Reject Jesus as Messiah” (as stated in bold print in his book), and if “Jesus refused by word and deed to be the Messiah” (be it the “reigning Messiah” or not), then, not only can it be said that “the Jews [in Jesus’ day] cannot be blamed for not accepting what was never offered” but that the Jews in any day cannot be blamed for not accepting Yeshua.

This again is a fundamental denial of the Word of God, and although In Defense of Israel claims that the “message of the gospel was from Israel, not to Israel,” Jesus, Peter, and Paul declared that the message of the gospel was to Israel first, and then from Israel to the nations (see Luke 24:47; Acts 1:8; 3:26; 13:32-39; Rom 1:16; in Paul’s words to the Jewish leaders in Rome, it was “for the sake of the hope of Israel” that he was bound in chains; Acts 28:20).

To be sure, there are a number of other errors found in the critical section of In Defense of Israel (including the myth that there was a so-called cup of the Messiah, the alleged fourth cup of the Passover meal that Yeshua supposedly refused to drink), but this is not the place to address those concerns, and to focus on the smaller problems would detract from the larger picture.

If you are not currently on our e-list, I would encourage you to sign up (www.revolutionnow.org) today. And let’s continue to make the truth known: Yeshua is the Messiah of Israel, the King of the Jews, the Savior of the World!

In Him,

Michael L. Brown, Ph.D.

********

Director, Coalition of Conscience (www.coalitionofconscience.org)

Host, Think It Thru TV (www.thinkitthru.tv)

About these ads

15 comments on “Dr. Michael Brown’s Critical Paper On “In Defense of Israel”

  1. Dr. Browns analysis is exremely refreshing! His indentification of Hagees writings as error and aiding abeting error seems a bit to soft though. I wonder what action will be taken toward Hagee since Johns writings define him as an author of anti christ doctrine? Will leaders of influence make formal charges and bring accountability with discipline as was done to Tony Campolo years ago?
    Thank you Dr. Brown for your public critique of this heresy made plausible. I agree whole heartedly with your analysis!
    Thank you Sola Dei Gloria for this posting.

    Richard Hanner

  2. Hi Richard…

    I wonder what action will be taken toward Hagee since Johns writings define him as an author of anti christ doctrine?

    Yes, im waiting to see also…What im praying doesn’t happen is it becomes yesterdays news, and things go on as usual: Hagee continues to preach/teach/write these blasphemies and the majority of Believers accept it and him.

    From what I read on Christian boards, thats exactly what is happening.

    What they don’t seem to realize is John Hagee’s soul is at stake, as well as those souls who take heed to his false teachings.

    Any of us can disagree or be in error on a point of doctrine–but the one thing we all as Christians always do, and have to, is to agree upon the Gospel message of salvation itself. Hagee is teaching a different Gospel….

  3. Another thing that surprises me is: Where are other Christian leader? Why there is not a single nationally known Christian leader raise up and challenge Hagee? Where is Pat Roberston, Dr. James Dobson, Joel Osteen, Franklin Graham, Kenneth Copeland, Jonathan Falwell, Benny Hinn and others?

    Hagee is preaching that “ANOTHER” Jesus mentioned in 2 Corinthinans 11:4

    In my opinion the apostate-in-chief made his obnoxious statements intentionally and after getting the heat from various Messianic Jewish sources he issued a phony apology.

  4. Well Victor, time will tell if we’ll see the more prominent Christian ‘leaders’ speak out…but you know what? Many of them preach and teach so many wacky things themselves, they probably won’t say much for fear of someone shinning a HUGE spot-light on their own false teachings.

    Our best bet is for people like you and I…virtually ‘no-bodies’ as far as the world is concerned but just as important in the body of Christ, to just keep presenting the truth every chance God affords us.

    If we can help to open up one persons eyes–ONE PERSON, then we will have done something wonderful in/by the power of the Holy Spirit! amen!!

    It doesn’t matter how many false teaches we have out there, truth will prevail in the end.

    God bless you Victor…Merry Christmas…

  5. Well Victor, time will tell if we’ll see the more prominent Christian ‘leaders’ speak out…but you know what? Many of them preach and teach so many wacky things themselves, they probably won’t say much for fear of someone shinning a HUGE spot-light on their own false teachings.

    Our best bet is for people like you and I…virtually ‘no-bodies’ as far as the world is concerned but just as important in the body of Christ, to just keep presenting the truth every chance God affords us.

    If we can help to open up one persons eyes–ONE PERSON, then we will have done something wonderful in/by the power of the Holy Spirit! amen!!

    It doesn’t matter how many false teaches we have out there, truth will prevail in the end.

    God bless you Victor…Merry Christmas…

  6. Thank you PJ!

    Merry Christmas to you too!

    I found this refutation to Hagee’s heresy by a prominent Messianic Jew, Aviad Cohen.

  7. Thanks Victor…

    I sure agree with the lead-in:

    John Hagee’s In Defense of Israel book is a demonic attack on the Jewish people,

    It is the enemy of the Gospel using him [Hagee] to keep the truth from people who need it…

  8. Hagee’ is probabaly too critical but I think, he is bringing to light these unclear issues to be clarified . The issue of Christian-Jew position on Jesus Christ is always unclear. The belief of his death , resurrection and the return of the same Jesus is supreme in the Christian faith. I thank Brown for assuring Chrsitans that they are in line with the Jews in their beliefs in Jesus’s crucifixion, resurrection and awating of his return.

    Glory be to God

  9. Guys,
    We are watching the great apostasy and falling away. Many will depart from the faith in the last days and there has to be a falling away from the Word of God for that to happen. I don’t care how much name it and claim it Hagee thinks he has, no one will ever out-prophesy Jesus. He said apostasy would come and it has. If people aren’t Emergent today, they are seeker-friendly, if not seeker-friendly, they are purpose-driven, if not purpose driven they are in Dominion Theology – do I need to go on?

    Anyhow, Hagee has been spreading his false Zionism for quite a while. Feed the flesh and blood needs of the Jews but DON’T PREACH THE GOSPEL to them. Something is seriously wrong with his theology and the sad thing is that this false Zionist movement that he has people giving literally billions to could be invested in missionaries to Israel which would be true Zionism.

    The falling away is here and I believe it is THE last sign needed in order “for this generation will not pass” till ALL THESE things be. People tend to forget the THESE. Matthew 24:34.

    God Bless,
    The Sacred Cowtipper

  10. In 2 John 10, we are not to open our door to someone bringing in a false doctrine. The TV is a large door. Me and my house chose to follow Jesus.

    • Bruce, im with you. The TV ‘preachers’ and i parted company many years ago. I found myself becoming hoarse from repeatedly yelling back at them through the TV. :-)

    • Who controls the Christian TV channels? Usually Christian business men. Almost every movement in the last 20 or 30 years is based on a pragmatic approach to evangelism that waters everything down as to not offend anyone. They think the ends justify the means and now we look at countless converts they think THEY made for Jesus living their lives unto themselves with no desire to live for the Lord. They are the Lord and Jesus is the servant. This is American Churchianity at its best. It’s so hard to find a decent church that hasn’t succumbed to any of these movements.

      Shame on those who have a huge pulpit to speak from and who will not say nothing about Hagee’s beliefs. A bunch of chickens at best and at worst-possibly wolves in sheep’s clothing.

    • Shame on those who have a huge pulpit to speak from and who will not say nothing about Hagee’s beliefs.

      Sadly, part of the answer as to why they don’t is primarily because many of these same men hold the same beliefs as Hagee, my friend.

      Thank you for commenting and God bless!

  11. Your spot on. I never thought I would see these days like this within the church but then again Jesus told us it would and He has never been wrong. God Bless!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

I Was a Teenage Dispensationalist

It's the end (of the end) of the world as we know it...

Disrupting Culture

A blog by Dr. Jonathan Welton

Holy Spirit Activism

Salvation, Miracles, Peace and Justice

Fishing For Men

paul the slave humbly serving Christ Jesus the Great Fisherman

Gralefrit Theology

Trying to explicate the inexplicable

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 463 other followers

%d bloggers like this: