5 Comments

Christians United for Israel (CUFI) – Where Your Donations Go…


Interesting article at Charisma: Where Your Israel Donation Really Goes 

One of the ministries highlighted was John Hagee’s Christian Zionism organization, CUFI (Christians United for Israel), which surprised me actually, for Charisma has run articles and messages about and from Hagee for years. What surprised me was the article pulled no punches concerning “what” CUFI really is and where donations to the organization go. 

quote,

Another example where many unwitting Christians think they are helping Messianics in Israel is Christians United for Israel, headed by founder John Hagee and its executive director, David Brog.

Hagee is undoubtedly the most public face of Christian support for Israel. Respected in both the evangelical and Jewish communities, he’s even garnered support from national media celebrities such as Glenn Beck. Politicians recognize his influence and curry his support, though this backfired for him when then-presidential candidate John McCain famously threw Hagee under the bus when a left-leaning Jew accused the pastor of being anti-Semitic. The charge was entirely unfounded and based on a fallacious misinterpretation of an obscure comment Hagee made in a sermon years ago.

Interestingly enough, leaders in the Jewish community were the first to jump to Hagee’s defense. They know he actually may be—as conservative Rabbi Aaron Rubinger from Orlando, Fla., said after attending a CUFI event—the best friend Israel has in America. Hagee has long been an avid supporter of Israel and was influenced by Derek Prince and other believers in the 1980s. Since he launched “A Night to Honor Israel” in 1981, the events have raised almost $80 million for humanitarian aid in Israel.

Charisma publisher Steve Strang attended “A Night to Honor Israel” in 2004 and was dumbfounded when he saw checks presented to three groups totaling $2.3 million.

“I’d never seen anything like it,” says Strang, who was sitting close enough to the recipients to see their emotional reaction to getting the checks.

To show his love and support for Israel, Hagee gives the raised money to charities that help the Jewish people. He makes his decisions on donations with the advice of Jewish friends. But it’s well known that none of the money gets to believers in Israel.

It’s a tightrope Hagee has walked for years. He’s friends with many Messianic believers and is quick to say he is supportive of believers in Israel. (In fact, several Messianic leaders were part of CUFI’s founding meeting in 2006.) But to publicly maintain peace with the Jewish community, which generally rejects Messianics, Hagee keeps his distance, much to the chagrin of the Messianic believers in Israel who often struggle to raise funds for their ministries.

Hagee also gets Jewish advice from CUFI’s own executive director. Brog is the powerhouse behind the Christian organization, yet he’s also a conservative (non-Messianic) Jew (*who unashamedly denies Jesus as the Messiah). He brought two other Jews on board: Shari Dollinger from Atlanta as one of his coordinators and Ari Morgenstern as communications director.

Morgenstern ensures CUFI’s messaging is consistent with what Brog wants—which is to convey that evangelical Christians support Israel, yet (to his Jewish supporters) are also “safe” because CUFI will never proselytize.

Brog, who was chief of staff to liberal Sen. Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania for seven years, is said to run CUFI like a political campaign. He has talking points, stays focused and rallies his constituency. He’s well liked by those who work with him and known for being a brilliant strategist. But one by one, the higher-profile Christian leaders who helped Hagee start CUFI are dropping off as the organization becomes more focused on political lobbying.

It’s no secret that one of the most powerful lobbying groups in Washington, D.C., the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), has long wanted a “Gentile arm,” and some believe they now have it in CUFI. Jewish leaders and philanthropists love to attend CUFI’s events to see the genuine enthusiasm and love expressed for Israel. Though there’s still rousing Christian music and prayer at these events, there’s most certainly no proselytizing. As a result, many wealthy Jews have pumped tens of thousands of dollars into CUFI.

Like Hagee, Brog has learned how to straddle the line between the evangelical and Jewish communities, and it shows in CUFI’s growth. The organization boasts of having more than 1 million “members,” though insiders know such membership consists of nothing but CUFI having your email address. There’s nothing to pay, nothing to sign. And even if you drop out, you’re still counted as a member. Given this, insiders say the number of actual donors is closer to 30,000 to 50,000.

Meanwhile, little is known about CUFI’s finances other than funds raised.

The organization says neither Hagee nor his wife, Diana, receives any compensation from CUFI. Yet when Charisma asked CUFI the same questions asked of other organizations in this report—particularly about administrative costs, leader salaries and budgetary breakdown—Morgenstern declined to comment beyond the following:

“The focus of Charisma’s article is on organizations whose missions center on ‘ministry programs in Israel and humanitarian aid to Israel.’ Having served as one of CUFI’s regional directors, Mr. Strang should be well aware that CUFI’s mission is entirely different: CUFI’s focus is on educating Christians in America about the biblical mandate to stand with Israel. CUFI simply has no place in this article.”

(*Any highlighting and emphasis was added by me)

5 comments on “Christians United for Israel (CUFI) – Where Your Donations Go…

  1. Oh no, I’m one of CUFI’s million + members, according to this article, because they have my email address. Oh well, it’s the best way to keep tabs on them.🙂

    It’s good to see such an article coming out of Charisma. I skimmed through the whole thing, and it was really well done.

    Unless I missed it, I don’t see which three groups received that $2.3 million at the “Night to Honor Israel” event in 2004 witnessed by Steve Strang.

    It was pretty clear from two different sections of Charisma’s article that CUFI is not financially transparent. I really wouldn’t be too surprised if I ever found out that funds are transferred between CUFI and AIPAC.

    • Yep, me to. ahaha!!! And you’re right, it is the best way to stay on top of what they’re doing.

      I was really surprised to see this at Charisma. Sounds like you were too.

      I really wouldn’t be too surprised if I ever found out that funds are transferred between CUFI and AIPAC.

      No, it wouldn’t surprise me either.

      Adam, i have to say, your most recent message is excellent! I was so glad to see (someone who knows how) put it all together.

    • Yes, I was surprised to see this at Charisma. They’re hard to figure out, though, because they allow editorials by J. Lee Grady (and once in a while another editor) that fly in the face of so many other things they publish and promote.

      Thank you for your kind words about my recent post. I’m glad you appreciated it.

    • Adam have you read anything about Steven Strang’s son, Cameron Strang? I hadn’t until recently.

      In one of the articles linked to in the post recommending your recent message, i saw the name Cameron Strang listed as one of “a new generation of Evangelical leaders (who) are “committed to spreading the Palestinian version of the conflict,”….in other words, Steven Strang’s son (i researched, and it is his son) has been accused of being in the “Palestinian camp” when it comes to the Middle East conflict”.

      None of that is true, but he does speak up publicly for peace and for Christians in Palestine (as well as followers of Jesus in Israel) and refuses to support certain actions taken by the Israeli government. This makes him in the opinion of both Zionists and Christian Zionists a “Palestinian-lover, hater of Israel”.

      What may be happening at Charisma is Steven Strang’s son “may” be having some input (or influence) concerning the online magazine?

      This was the article where i originally saw his name mentioned. Afterward i read some other info about him and his work for peace by doing a search.

    • Hi PJ,

      No, I hadn’t read anything about Cameron Strang. Thanks for sharing all that. You’re very possibly correct about Cameron influencing the online magazine in that way.

      It sure is polarizing that way, isn’t it? If someone loves the Palestinians, they must be “a Jew hater” or “an Israel hater.” Or so we’re told… That kind of thinking leaves out the truth that God gives us the grace to love Jews, love Palestinians, love Brazilians, and to be pro-Palestinian, pro-Jewish, pro-Brazilian, etc. all at the same time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Rooted and Grounded In Christ

Teaching Sound Doctrine & Glorifying Christ

Music from Broken Chords

Down in the human heart, crush'd by the tempter, Feelings lie buried that grace can restore; Touched by a loving heart, wakened by kindness Chords that were broken will vibrate once more. From the Hymn "Rescue the Perishing" by Fanny J. Crosby

Lead Me

"Evil men do not understand justice, but those who seek the LORD understand it fully."

I Was a Teenage Dispensationalist

It's the end (of the end) of the world as we know it...

Disrupting Culture

A blog by Dr. Jonathan Welton

%d bloggers like this: