There are many articles and teachings posted at Christian blogs, Apologetic and Discernment websites concerning the false signs and manifestations which have increased and are increasing within the Church-World today: I even post quite a few here. We all need these reminders so as to stay alert to the false and demonic as these type of manifestations signs and wonders, not of God, will surely increase before the Great Day of the Coming of our Lord. We know this for the Word tells us…
As of late though, the Lord has been reminding me not to become caught up in only seeking to detect the false, to the neglect of having faith in the real: The true gifts, miracles, signs, wonders, and manifestations of the Holy Spirit.
I believe this reminder was necessary, mainly because any one of us can become callused or jaded in our faith, if by nothing else, the sheer magnitude of the false and demonic. Personally, I don’t want to be found guilty of that.
While we should pray for discernment by which to recognize the false, we should also pray to know or discern the true. Many Christians today wrongly believe discernment is only for the one purpose and not the other.
John Piper at Desiring God, wrote a (3) part teaching on Signs and Wonders: Then and Now, which I want to share with you. Maybe like me, you need a reminder of the continuing gifts of the Spirit and the true signs and wonders of God in operation today. Or perhaps you are one who believes these do not exist in today’s Church: either way, I hope this 3 part teaching will bless you…
“Now Peter and John went up together into the temple at the hour of prayer, being the ninth hour. And a certain man lame from his mother’s womb was carried, whom they laid daily at the gate of the temple which is called Beautiful, to ask alms of them that entered into the temple; Who seeing Peter and John about to go into the temple asked an alms. And Peter, fastening his eyes upon him with John, said, Look on us. And he gave heed unto them, expecting to receive something of them. Then Peter said, Silver and gold have I none; but such as I have give I thee: In the name of Jesus Christ of Nazareth rise up and walk. And he took him by the right hand, and lifted him up: and immediately his feet and ankle bones received strength. And he leaping up stood, and walked, and entered with them into the temple, walking, and leaping, and praising God” Acts 3: 1-8
Part 1: Are Wonders against the Word?
I am one of those Baptist General Conference people who believes that “signs and wonders” and all the spiritual gifts of 1 Corinthians 12:8-10 are valid for today and should be “earnestly desired” (1 Corinthians 14:1) for the edification of the church and the spread of the gospel. I agree with the words of Martyn Lloyd-Jones, preached in 1965:
It is perfectly clear that in New Testament times, the gospel was authenticated in this way by signs, wonders and miracles of various characters and descriptions. . . . Was it only meant to be true of the early church? . . . The Scriptures never anywhere say that these things were only temporary – never! There is no such statement anywhere. (The Sovereign Spirit, pp. 31-32)
My purpose here is not to defend any contemporary pattern of ministry. Instead I want to give Biblical reasons for my conviction and Biblical answers to some objections. This conviction flows out of my God-centered, Bible-based, Calvinistic commitment to the sovereignty of God and the supremacy of his revealed Word. It is not a departure from any truth I have championed in the past.
This question determines my starting point: Is the experience of signs and wonders detrimental to the centrality of Scripture and preaching? In other words, does it depreciate the supernatural power of God’s written and preached word; does it contradict the sufficiency of the gospel to save sinners; does the search for signs signify a loss of confidence in the word of the cross?
The reason I take this question so seriously is that it is rooted in Biblical texts. Romans 1:16 says, “The gospel is the power of God unto salvation.” The gospel, not signs and wonders.
Paul says, “Jews demand signs, Greeks seek wisdom, but we preach Christ crucified . . . the power of God . . .” (1 Corinthians 1:22-23). The “word of the cross is . . . the power of God” (1 Corinthians 1:18).
Sign-seeking is a diversion from the power of Christ crucified. Thus Jesus himself said, “An evil and adulterous generation seeks for a sign” (Matthew 12:39; 16:4).
But there is a fatal flaw in bringing these texts against every longing for signs and wonders. They would prove too much. If desiring signs and wonders dilutes the power of the gospel-then the early Christians and the apostles themselves were wicked and adulterous, because they so passionately wanted God to do signs and wonders alongside their powerful preaching.
For example, Peter and John and the disciples prayed in Acts 4:29-30,
“Lord, look upon their threats, and grant to thy servants to speak thy word with all boldness, while you stretch out your hand to heal, and signs and wonders are performed through the name of your holy servant Jesus.”
Here we have godly men and women praying for signs and wonders to happen in the name of Jesus. And Luke does not portray them as a “wicked and adulterous generation” for doing so. They are exemplary.
Not only that, Luke himself labors in the book of Acts to show how valuable signs and wonders are in winning people to Christ. He does not portray them as a threat to the gospel, but as a witness to the gospel. The reason the church prayed so passionately in Acts 4:30 for signs and wonders to happen is because God was using them to bring multitudes to Christ.
I count at least 17 times where miracles help lead to conversions in the book of Acts. The clearest examples are in Acts 9:34-35 and 9:40,42. Peter heals Aeneas, and Luke says, “And all the residents of Lydda and Sharon saw him, and they turned to the Lord.” Peter raises Tabitha from the dead, and Luke says, “It became known to all Joppa, and many believed in the Lord.”
There is no doubt that the working of miracles-signs and wonders-helped bring people to Christ. That is what Luke wants us to see and that is why the Christians prayed for signs and wonders to happen.
This raises two questions:
1) Why was the prayer for signs and wonders in Acts 4:30 not wicked and adulterous, in view of what Jesus said in Matthew 12:39? and
2) Why did the seeking and occurrence of signs and wonders in the missionary effort of first century Christians not contradict the sufficiency of the gospel as the power of God unto salvation?
The answer to the first question comes from the context of Jesus’ indictment of sign-seeking. Seeking signs from God is “wicked and adulterous” when the demand for more and more evidence comes from a resistant heart and simply covers up an unwillingness to believe. If we are carrying on a love affair with the world, and our husband, Jesus, after a long separation, comes to us and says, “I love you and I want you back,” one of the best ways to protect our adulterous relationship with the world is to say, “You’re not really my husband; you don’t really love me. Prove it. Give me some sign.”
If that’s the way we demand a sign, then we are a wicked and adulterous generation.
But if we come to God with a heart aching with longing for vindication of his glory and the salvation of sinners, then we are not wicked and adulterous. We are a faithful wife, only wanting to honor our husband.
The answer to the second question-the question why signs and wonders need not detract from the power of the gospel-comes from Luke’s own explanation of how wonders and the word are related.
In Acts 14:3 he says that Paul and Barnabas “remained a long time [in Iconium] speaking boldly for the Lord, who bore witness to the word of his grace, granting signs and wonders to be done by their hands”.
This is utterly crucial: signs and wonders are God’s witness to his word. They are not in competition with the word. They are not against the word. They are not over the word. They are divine witnesses to the value and truth and necessity and centrality of the word (see also Hebrews 2:4; Mark 16:20).
Signs and wonders are not the saving word of grace; they are God’s secondary testimony to the word of his grace. Signs and wonders do not save. They are not the power of God unto salvation. They do not transform the heart-any more than music or art or drama which accompany the gospel.
Signs and wonders can be imitated by Satan (2 Thessalonians 2:9; Matthew 24:24), but the gospel is utterly contrary to his nature. What changes the heart and saves the soul is the self-authenticating glory of Christ seen in the message of the gospel (2 Corinthians 3:18 – 4:6).
But even if signs and wonders can’t save the soul, they can, if God pleases, shatter the shell of disinterest; they can shatter the shell of cynicism; they can shatter the shell of false religion. Like every other good witness to the word of grace, they can help the fallen heart to fix its gaze on the gospel where the soul-saving, self-authenticating glory of the Lord shines.
Therefore the early church longed for God to stretch forth his hand to heal, and that signs and wonders be done in the name of Jesus.
The fact that the early Christians prayed so earnestly for signs and wonders (Acts 4:30) is all the more striking when you realize that they, of all generations were in least need of supernatural authentication. This was the generation whose preaching (of Peter and Stephen and Philip and Paul) was more anointed than the preaching of any generation following. If any preaching was the power of God unto salvation and did not need accompanying signs and wonders, it was this preaching.
Moreover this was the generation that had more immediate and more compelling evidence of the truth of the resurrection than any generation since.
Hundreds of eyewitnesses to the risen Lord were alive in Jerusalem. If any generation in the history of the church knew the power of preaching and the authentication of the gospel from first-hand evidence of the resurrection, it was this one. Yet it was they who prayed passionately for God to stretch forth his hand in signs and wonders.
Therefore I conclude that in our zeal for the centrality of the word we should not go beyond the word by making signs and wonders enemies of the word of the cross.
Nobody was more jealous for the power of the word than Paul. Yet he described his mission as Christ working through him “in the power of signs and wonders” (Romans 15:19).
Were these the unique “sign of an apostle” and thus not valid for us? I don’t think so.
That will be the question answered in the next section.
To be continued…
I needed to read this today. It’s so easy to get caught up in negativity or just plain unbelief and lose our joy when we just focus on trying to keep up with what kook or false teacher said on this or that. It wears me out and this is uplifting! There is joy and pleasure in serving Christ, we need a reminder once in awhile that the God of the Universe loves us, and is intimately involved in our lives and he cares for us. Just when we get too legalistic, he can heal and restore us. Praise his holy name!
Thanks for posting this PJ, and I hope you had a wonderful Christmas and Happy New Year!
Good article, Sis. God showed me last year that I’m prone to throw out the real to avoid the false.
We become so extremely opposed to the counterfeit, that we begin to reject the genuine so as to not even chance it being the counterfeit.
God didn’t call us to walk in fear, tho.
This little teaching blessed me too guys!
Like you B, i needed it…
It is easy to get so caught up in seeing only the false that we become blind to the real. Every so often the Holy Spirit will have to remind me of that, 🙂
I’m looking forward to posting the rest of this teaching by John Piper!
Lord, we humbly request a renewed faith to see past the false so as to see your miraculous power at work today.. amen.
Excellent reminder, PJ, thank you.
I have noticed over and over in Scripture that it is only a tender, believing heart that is able to see the manifest glory of God.
God has an equal measuring stick, and if we’re not careful, even a sincere quest for truth and its defense is not enough to keep us free from error. Without a broken and contrite heart residing within, we can become hardened ourselves while raising our fist against the other side–and that in the name of Truth!
I love the story in Joshua where it reveals the truth about taking sides: Joshua 5:13-15 says,
13 Now when Joshua was near Jericho, he looked up and saw a man standing in front of him with a drawn sword in his hand. Joshua went up to him and asked, “Are you for us or for our enemies?” 14 “Neither,” he replied, “but as commander of the army of the LORD I have now come.” Then Joshua fell facedown to the ground in reverence, and asked him, “What message does my Lord have for his servant?” 15 The commander of the LORD’s army replied, “Take off your sandals, for the place where you are standing is holy.” And Joshua did so.
Let us not miss the holy by spending so much of God’s precious time watching only the profane.
I pray a blessing to all who render their hearts to the Lord in this way. Get and stay only on His side! And may you see the glory of God in your everyday.
This is fast becoming my favorite blog site…A Baptist who believes in signs and wonders, a tribulation bound Church and recognizes Todd Bentley and gang as demonic….I thought I was alone!
🙂 AHA! You’re not alone Laura…
There are many of us out there who just want to be the ‘Church’….even it it means we don’t always follow after a particular denomination’s theology.
I wanted to tell you how much I appreciate your blog. It is very well written and thoughtful and full of helpful insight for the confusing world of modern day Christianity. I have not commented in a while but I felt led to on this post.
I agree with what is said here: “signs and wonders are God’s witness to his word. They are not in competition with the word. They are not against the word. They are not over the word. They are divine witnesses to the value and truth and necessity and centrality of the word..”
I have personally experienced many supernatural manifestations. Including a supernatural deliverance and healing from alcoholism from a ministering angel. Hebrews 1:14 “Are they not all ministering spirits sent forth to minister for those who will inherit salvation?”
Recently I asked God for confirmation on something that I just can’t believe is happening to me and He showed me the scripture:
“God also bearing witness both with signs and wonders, with various miracles, and gifts of the Holy Spirit, according to His own will?” Heb 2:4
The Lord does what He wants , when he wants. Our God is also a supernatural God. The “gifts” that He decides to bestow upon us are a blessing to us and a way that He shows us His love, affection and His longing to be with us.
If we were able to spent any time in the spiritual world we would learn that signs and wonders are the nature of the spirit world. And that includes Satan and the Principalities of darkness.
The thing that I find interesting is that I have ASKED God to speak to me, to send me dreams, visions and divine revelation. I have told Him I want to know Him and see Him and long to spend time with Him. I seek after the glory of God! BUT I also crucify my flesh daily and repent and stay at the foot of the cross. I pray and fast and have made a covenant of obedience. Most Christians today can’t even spend one hour a day with God!
It is hard to share these things with other people and especially Christians because the first thing they say or think is “Are you sure it’s from God”, or “Why don’t I have these kinds of experiences?” I say to that “Have you asked for them?” Of course God knows our heart and he knows the spirit in which we ask and seek after something. But so does Satan, who is all too willing to oblige us if we are not walking UPRIGHT with God.
In closing I encourage all to mediate on this scripture:
“‘Call to Me, and I will answer you, and show you great and mighty things, which you do not know.’ Jer 33:3
But do it with a pure heart and a repentant soul and your God will hear you!
In Christ, Sara
Discernment is so crucial in every aspect of our walk with the Lord. It cannot be said enough!
Concerning signs and wonders: Is there NT scripture that verifies that God sends or sent a “glory cloud” to people to show His presence to the NT church? My immediate thoughts: Jesus is the Glory of God. The Holy Spirit resides within us, so why would we need some mist or cloud to prove God is present with us. Doesn’t the Scripture say, “Emmanuel, God With Us”?
I’ve thought for years that this was a very helpful series by Piper. Nothing profound, but still solid and well articulated.
Yes, it’s very simply written too.
Many of the teachings on the topic are out of balance, one way or the other, but Piper laid his out relying on the scriptures.
this was uplifting. i went to a church that got into all the false bill johnson crap. honestly ive become jaded in my faith but i know who my savior is and its something ill have to work through.
Just wanted to comment on the signs and wonders…
I do agree that Todd Bentley needs salvation or deliverance from the Spirit of _______(unsure)
The Lord is working signs and wonders in my life that has been in the works since Nov 2008, I am going from Glory to Glory. There is definitely an outpouring of the Holy Spirit that I never experienced before.
Sara is correct, prayer, fasting and obedience are essential.
(CAPS DUE TO PASSION)
THIS OUTPOURING OF SIGNS AND WONDERS ARE TO BE WITNESSED BY UNBELIEVERS ( FOR THE SAKE OF SALVATION) AND FOR THE BELIEVERS ( THAT HAVE LITTLE FAITH AND/OR DISOBEDIENT)
I will give you the Scripture reference that he is teaching me now (Ephesians 3) …
He is working on me through the Holy Spirit with this new GIFT…..I am writing a book because this journey is so fascnating.. all for the Glory of God
In regards to false prophets and evil spirits, Satan has unleashed more evil also on the world as well… and the younger generation is the target…. we need to wonder why??????
Doubt, Confusion etc are not of GOD…. WE MUST PRAY/FAST THROUGH THOSE THOUGHTS TOTALLY RELY ON GOD WE ARE NEVER ALONE.( JOHN 14)
FAITH WITHOUT WORKS IS DEAD.
There soo many signs n wonders in da churches that it can be hard 2 know da difference unless u know about new age miracles in da church.
I have big doubts about whether the term “outpouring of the Spirit” when used as an ONGOING event. I believe all of the OT prophecies concerning the outpouring of the Holy Spirit refer to Pentecost and the individual infilling of each Christian thereafter. Not some on-going, touchy, feely phenomenon that produces signs, wonders, chills and thrills. If we are filled with the Holy Spirit and preach the Gospel and obey Jesus as laid out in his Word, the signs and wonders follow, but not because God is continually REpouring-out His Spirit.
In my first sentence I meant to say:
I have big doubts about whether the term “outpouring of the Spirit”, when used as ONGOING event, IS SCRIPTURAL.
quoting Tom : “i went to a church that got into all the false bill johnson crap”
I wouldn’t say Bill Johnson is false, but I would say that there is some error that should be purged from his ministry. I find a lot of what he says thought-provoking, prayerful, and Biblical.
quoting takitheterrible: “I find a lot of what he (Bill Johnson) says thought-provoking, prayerful, and Biblical”.
I will say with confidence that EVERYTHING about Bill Johnson is heresy, false and UNBiblical. 😦
Got doubts? Check out the in-depth research of the man….
quoting Sylvia: I will say with confidence that EVERYTHING about Bill Johnson is heresy, false and UNBiblical.
Everything means everything, and of course you don’t mean everything.
I disagree with Johnson’s assessment that Jesus Christ was “born again,” but I don’t find him to be a proponent of kenosis as that blog suggests. I read “Heaven Invades Earth” and I get his point, but I vehemently dislike the terminology employed. He should’ve used a better allusion to describe that Jesus did His miracles as a Spirit-filled man, and not G-d.
I believe that is a Christian belief, though. Jesus did not do His miracles as G-d, though He was and always will be G-d.